Wednesday, August 21, 2019

Natural selection and the battle for your child's soul

I get why folks want to ban the teaching of natural selection as the driving force behind the evolution of all living things on Earth. A child who grasps natural selection faces a fundamental challenge to her place in the universe.


While some folks might encourage a child's quest to seek awareness of her place in the universe, most parents (in this part of the world, anyway) already have a pretty good idea what they want their children to believe, and usually because they believe that they are looking out for the child's best interests.

No one wants their baby to go to Hell, so kneel before the Tabernacle.
No one wants their child batting last in Little League, so keep the back elbow up.

Much of what passes for understanding evolution in this country is, well, just another form of religion. You pick a side, you wave a banner, you demonize the others. We cannot help ourselves--our tendency to religiosity may be built into our genes.

Natural selection is a simple model to grasp (though the vastness of geologic time it takes extends beyond my imagination). Its ramifications blow the mind. 

Humans were not, it turns out, inevitable. The earthworm is as evolved as you. The countless other living beings among us do not exist for us, they exist with us, likely for the same unfathomable (though explainable) reasons we exist.

I still find comfort making the Sign of the Cross, and if you push, yes, a big part of who I am believes that it matters beyond whatever psychological relief it brings. I doubt I would believe that if I were raised Hindu, but I wasn't, and my beliefs are strong and deeply ingrained, if (perhaps) irrational.


Natural selection rubs up against my less than rational beliefs. Natural selection will do the same to a thinking child, no matter what her religion.

Teachers want a child to use her mind. Her parents fear for her soul. I do not know what either "mind" or "soul" means, but I do know that if you believe that the mind and soul are competing entities, evolution by natural selection is going to be perceived as a fundamental threat to your child's well-being.

I am a science teacher; I teach biology; I will share the fundamental "tenet" central to understanding the diversity of life on Earth.

I am not going to ask a child to "believe in" evolution--there is nothing to "believe in" in science beyond  the acceptance of the observable natural world as the premise for the models and explanations used in science, trust in rational thought, and a willingness to alter or abandon prior understandings when new contradictory evidence emerges.


I sympathize with the parents who believe that they are fighting for their child's soul, but I am an American living in a republic dependent on a thinking citizenry bound by our Constitution. If you want a public education system that favors religion over rational thought, there are plenty of theocracies around the globe doing just that.





Glad I teach in New Jersey.....

31 comments:

Europa said...

Europa Educational Solutions providing home tutoring services in Bangalore, Hyderabad and Delhi. Visit the website of europaeducations for more information about our service. Or type home tuition near me in google.

Europa said...

Taldeen is a newly formed plastic manufacturing company in Saudi Arabia. They are producing plastic products for B2B purpose. Taldeen is categorized their products into four different categories. That are pipes solutions, handling solutions, agricultural solutions and water tank solutions. Visit the website for more information about these products.

mcafee.com/activate said...

I really happy found this website eventually. Really informative and inoperative, Thanks for the blog and effort! Please keep sharing more such blog www.mcafee.com/activate

John Shaw said...

I like your content very much, good work, keep it up. follow below links for useful security information:

mcafee.com/activate
www.mcafee.com/activate

Bacosofttech.com said...

I Like your content this is very impressive blog post n i have some links to share here Cash Counter

CSS Founder said...

Are you looking for the best website designing company in Noida? Connect with CSS Founder to get the world class website design for your business online business as you know the first impression is the last impression.

Unknown said...

Thanks for sharing this nice and informative blog. Keep posting like this.
Upcoming residential projects in sector 79 Noida

Al Mumtaz said...

It's very nice and amazing article that you have posted here. Thanks for this. Tent Supplier in UAE

CSS Founder said...

Thank you so much for sharing this blog with us, it is really amazing valuable and informative.
website design company in bangalore

Aquapro said...

Thankyou for sharing the data which is beneficial for me and others likewise to see
Brackish Water Desalination 150000 GPD R.O. System Djibouti

Vedasrivastu said...

You have shared really very nice information. Please keep posting like this so that we can get knowledge from your blog. I hope I will read your new blog soon.
Vastu consultants in Dubai for property planning in Dubai

Rio Resort Lansdowne said...

Interesting post. I Have Been wondering about this issue, so thanks for posting. It's really a very informative and Useful post. Thanks
Resorts in Lansdowne

PromoteDial said...

Are you looking for the best SEO Company in ahmedabad that can help in getting your business goals? If yes then you must connect with us.

Akash Kanaujiya said...

We are the best website design company that provides services in this digital world, if you want to increase your business through a website, then contact us. Website designing company in meerut

Gaurav's Blog said...

Thank you because you have been willing to share information with us. we will always appreciate all you have done here 10000 GPD Reverse Osmosis System

Steadfast services said...

Thank you for providing this information, this is a very useful blog, we are waiting for your next blog, please keep doing it.
Immigration consultant in Dubai

kingpure said...


Nice Post Your content is very inspiring and appriciating I really like it.
<a href="https://kingpure.in/product-category/premium-series> premium series SS Water Tanks in India</a>

Anonymous said...

Thank you for very useful information.
<a href="https://kingpure.in/product-category/luxury-series> Luxury Series Stainless Steel Water Tanks in India</a>

Anonymous said...

Thank you for very useful information.
product-category-luxury-series> Luxury Series Stainless Steel Water Tanks in India

Anonymous said...

Thank you for very useful information.
https://kingpure.in/product-category/premium-series-stainless-steel-water-tank/

PROMOTEDIAL said...

“Content Marketing is not simply a campaign or a tactic, it’s a commitment.” Seo Company in Indianapolis

website company said...

Designers are responsible artists. Whether it is web designing or development it requires a sense of imagination for looking at the output even before it is published. web design company in nottigham

turkeysvisa said...

“The World is a Book And Those Who Do Not Travel Read Only One Page” Turkey visa apply online

RSM Enterprises said...

Vardenafil 20mg Tablets are taken orally 25 - 60 minutes before sexual activity or as directed by your doctor. Snovitra 20mg Pills come with a patient information booklet that should be read carefully.

aquapro said...

Live pure, drink pure. 4500 GPD Reverse Osmosis System

Hotel Green Palms said...

You have shared really very nice information. Please keep posting like this so that we can get knowledge from your blog. I hope I will read your new blog soon. best hotels in Lansdowne

Ryan said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Ryan said...

Great blog and article! Sending this over since it might be helpful too for students and teachers: Expontum - Helps students, teachers, and researchers quickly find research knowledge gaps and identify what research projects have been completed before.

Also related to the article, some of our knowledge gaps related to the evolution: Evolution Knowledge Gaps.

Website Designing Company in Delhi said...

CSS Founder is an exceptional website designing company in Delhi that is ahead of the rest. With their innovative and creative approach, they consistently deliver excellent websites that are not only visually appealing but also highly functional.

E visa Dubai said...

If you are a UK passport holder and planning a trip to Dubai, you may be wondering about visa requirements. Thankfully, in recent years it has become much easier and more convenient to obtain a Dubai visa for UK Passport. Using the e Visa Dubai website, you can easily apply for and receive your Dubai Visa online. This article will guide you through the process and provide you with all the necessary information to ensure a smooth and hassle-free visa application experience.

Buystrip said...

Snovitra 20mg (Vardenafil) - Best Price Online
Snovitra 20, containing Vardenafil 20mg, is a powerful solution for men seeking reliable erectile dysfunction pills.