Wednesday, August 21, 2019

Natural selection and the battle for your child's soul

I get why folks want to ban the teaching of natural selection as the driving force behind the evolution of all living things on Earth. A child who grasps natural selection faces a fundamental challenge to her place in the universe.


While some folks might encourage a child's quest to seek awareness of her place in the universe, most parents (in this part of the world, anyway) already have a pretty good idea what they want their children to believe, and usually because they believe that they are looking out for the child's best interests.

No one wants their baby to go to Hell, so kneel before the Tabernacle.
No one wants their child batting last in Little League, so keep the back elbow up.

Much of what passes for understanding evolution in this country is, well, just another form of religion. You pick a side, you wave a banner, you demonize the others. We cannot help ourselves--our tendency to religiosity may be built into our genes.

Natural selection is a simple model to grasp (though the vastness of geologic time it takes extends beyond my imagination). Its ramifications blow the mind. 

Humans were not, it turns out, inevitable. The earthworm is as evolved as you. The countless other living beings among us do not exist for us, they exist with us, likely for the same unfathomable (though explainable) reasons we exist.

I still find comfort making the Sign of the Cross, and if you push, yes, a big part of who I am believes that it matters beyond whatever psychological relief it brings. I doubt I would believe that if I were raised Hindu, but I wasn't, and my beliefs are strong and deeply ingrained, if (perhaps) irrational.


Natural selection rubs up against my less than rational beliefs. Natural selection will do the same to a thinking child, no matter what her religion.

Teachers want a child to use her mind. Her parents fear for her soul. I do not know what either "mind" or "soul" means, but I do know that if you believe that the mind and soul are competing entities, evolution by natural selection is going to be perceived as a fundamental threat to your child's well-being.

I am a science teacher; I teach biology; I will share the fundamental "tenet" central to understanding the diversity of life on Earth.

I am not going to ask a child to "believe in" evolution--there is nothing to "believe in" in science beyond  the acceptance of the observable natural world as the premise for the models and explanations used in science, trust in rational thought, and a willingness to alter or abandon prior understandings when new contradictory evidence emerges.


I sympathize with the parents who believe that they are fighting for their child's soul, but I am an American living in a republic dependent on a thinking citizenry bound by our Constitution. If you want a public education system that favors religion over rational thought, there are plenty of theocracies around the globe doing just that.





Glad I teach in New Jersey.....

16 comments:

Europa said...

Europa Educational Solutions providing home tutoring services in Bangalore, Hyderabad and Delhi. Visit the website of europaeducations for more information about our service. Or type home tuition near me in google.

Europa said...

Taldeen is a newly formed plastic manufacturing company in Saudi Arabia. They are producing plastic products for B2B purpose. Taldeen is categorized their products into four different categories. That are pipes solutions, handling solutions, agricultural solutions and water tank solutions. Visit the website for more information about these products.

IBPHUB   said...

Indian Business Pages is a commercial information search service provider with accurate and authentic data of micro, SME and MNC businesses across India. The business is organized on a simple 3-tiered network that enables us to reach every corner of India.

Mazhar said...

Are you looking for Advertising Agency in Riyadh. Here, I would like you to share best Branding Agency Riyadh & Marketing Agency Riyadh

Mazhar said...

Here is the best Digital Marketing Agency Riyadh. If you are looking for a social media agency Riyadh, the above(link) company is the best

www.norton.com/setup said...

Great information, i was searching of this kind of information, thank you very much for sharing with us. i also have some links to share norton.com/setup

mcafee.com/activate said...

I really happy found this website eventually. Really informative and inoperative, Thanks for the blog and effort! Please keep sharing more such blog www.mcafee.com/activate

thenortonsetup.com said...

Nice post, you give the clear idea of the topic and I subscribed your blog, I have some links to share here norton.com/setup


www.norton.com/setup

avg-retail.com said...

I'm so glad and enjoyed your BLOG , It is very informative on subject or topic and Thanks For Sharing this post. I have something to share here www.avg.com/retail

www.avg.com/activate

avg.com/activate

avg.com/retail

thenortonsetup.com said...

This is a very impressive blog post, I like the way you describe things. I have also something to share here
norton.com/setup
www.norton.com/setup

James Tech said...

Great information ! I like the way you write the topic. I have some useful links to share.

Mcafee.com/activate
www.Mcafee.com/activate

John Shaw said...

I like your content very much, good work, keep it up. follow below links for useful security information:

mcafee.com/activate
www.mcafee.com/activate

Bacosofttech.com said...

I Like your content this is very impressive blog post n i have some links to share here Cash Counter

Norton Product Key said...


Dear Author, you have written a mind-blowing blog all content was very informative and useable information I would like to say thank you so much for sharing such useful information with us and wish you all the best for upcoming comment. I have also something to share here I hope you will like my comment. norton.com/setup
www.norton.com/setup, Norton product key

Ash said...

www.norton.com/setup
solutions.brother.com/windows
Malwarebytes unable to connect to service
virus alert from Microsoft this computer is blocked
avast virus definitions won't update
canon.com/ijsetup

Ash said...

epson connect printer setup utility
www.avg.com/retail
how to install Norton antivirus on Windows 10
how do i reinstall norton 360 without disc
support.brother.com/windows